| Nat | Player | Club | Pos | Age | Rt | |
 | Tony Rocha | Orange County SC | D(LC),DM,M(C) | 30 | 77 | |
 | Carlos Bernárdez | CD Real Sociedad | F(C) | 31 | 74 | |
 | Michael Salazar | Miami FC | AM(RL),F(RLC) | 31 | 73 | |
| Eugene Martínez | Verdes FC | D(C) | 26 | 72 | |
| Krisean López | Verdes FC | AM(RL),F(RLC) | 25 | 70 | |
| Angelo Cappello | FC Halifax Town | AM(RL),F(RLC) | 22 | 65 | |
| Deshawon Nembhard | Central Valley Fuego | D,DM(L) | 29 | 65 | |
| Mike Atkinson | Hungerford Town | D(RC),DM(C) | 33 | 63 |